The Utilization of free speech: A discussion on the First Amendment of the U.S.

-

 The Utilization of free speech: A discussion on the First Amendment of the U.S.


Despite its exalted status, the First Amendment of the U.S has always been the subject of controversy in practice. The First amendment protects the freedom of Speech of all citizens. While on the face this may seem perfect and flawless and a true upholding of the citizens rights, behind the curtain this has been the subject to a lot of scrutiny. What seems to be the problem is the First Amendment’s protection of “hate speech,”. Due to this inclusion of hate speech, Critics believe that freedom of speech in practice has become a tool of oppression, one that leads to physical violence.

A Vivid Example of this is the events that took place on 6 January, 2021 i.e is when the battery of staunch Trump supporters stormed the Capitol Building. The Violent riots that left many injured and 5 people dead, started essentially with the hate speech and spread of ultra rightest propaganda on the Social Media platforms.

So where does the problem arise from? The First amendment is one of the most liberal fundamental rights. Even in India itself, there have been restrictions put on the freedom of speech.




" The Constitution guarantees freedom of speech and expression. But this freedom is subject to reasonable restrictions imposed I by the State relating to a) Defamation; b) Contempt of Court; c) Decency or morality; d) Security of the State; e) Friendly relations with foreign State; f) incitement to an offence; g) public order; h) Maintenance of the sovereignty and integrity of India."


In Comparison, there are almost no restrictions on the freedom of Speech in the U.S. But that means that there also not a curb on the Hate speech, speech that promotes violence and propagates divide and inferiority of certain sections of society.

The biggest problem is that hate speech defies a clear and consistent definition, let alone a workable legal standard. With no consistent definition of hate speech, The first amendment can't be amended.


The First Amendment of US is more than 230 year old. It is time that we discuss as to how it can be amended. For that it is imminent that we start working to build a working definition of hate speech.

Secondly, it is important that we promote Education, especially on media ethics as it will help Counter hate speech.

There is a need to encourage conflict-sensitive reporting and multicultural awareness campaigns as they might help dispel the ‘us’ against ‘them’ prejudice. We can do this by-

Teaching journalists conflict-sensitive reporting skills.


Multicultural awareness campaigns should emphasize knowledge about and respect for the diversity of cultures and tradition
There is a need to end impunity against hate crime by establishing monitoring and evaluation units in newsroom units that would monitor hate speech trends, compile reports, and bringing these to the attention of key institutions and society. Action can then been taken accordingly.

We need to engage in advocacy to highlight hate speech trends of concern as well as to express sympathy and support to targeted individuals or groups.

We need to encourage conflict-sensitive reporting and multicultural awareness campaigns as they might help eliminate the ‘us’ against ‘them’ bias. We can do this by-

1) Creating a special education curriculum wherein students are taught about equality and unity in diversity.

2)Teaching journalists conflict-sensitive reporting skills.

3)Multicultural awareness campaigns should emphasize knowledge about and respect for the diversity of cultures and traditions

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

should the house allow children to sue their parents for religious indoctrination?

-
Image
                                THW allows children to sue their parents for religious indoctrination Hello everyone. Today, I will be writing against this motion i.e THW allows children to sue their parents for religious indoctrination. This is just my side of the argument that I wanted to put forward for discussion and I am in no way forcing my thoughts about this topic on anyone. I would first like to define the important terms in this motion. Religious Indoctrination refers to a process of imparting doctrine in an authoritative way. Secondly, Children refer to minors under the age of 16 and suing is taking complicated legal action against a person. First, I would like to state that I in no way supports religious indoctrination and the opposition believes that they should be given some sort of help. But we need to acknowledge the fact that Children or Minors are too young and naive to make their own deci...
Read more

Law for the Man or Man for the Law? : A discussion in light of the 50th anniversary of Kesavananda Bharati case

-
Law for the Man or Man for the Law? : A discussion in light of the 50th anniversary of Kesavananda Bharati case 66 days. 701 pages worth of judgment, with a unique yet equally fundamental opinion for 11 of the 13 judges that presided over the case. Needless to say, Kesavananda Bharati vs. State of Kerala was the most important landmark case that made it to the pages of Indian history. The case was concluded on 24th April, 1973 with the judge's ruling acting as a temporary fix for the long running disputes between the State and the Court and aiming to provide an answer for two principal questions; these namely being a) How far can the government work for the welfare of the society when it is at the expense of an individual's fundamental rights? And b) How far reaching is the government’s right to amend our Constitution that is deemed to be a ‘living document’? The deliberation remains, did the ruling manage to provide us with a satisfactory answer? Well the answer is both yes an...
Read more

Orientalism behind the curtains

-
Image
Cultural appropriation I dream of Jeannie Today I wanted to discuss cultural appropriation in one of the most famous series of its time i.e I dream of Jeanie. I Dream of Jeannie was written by Sidney Sheldon from 1965-70. The show is about American astronaut Major Nelson, who accidentally rescues a genie after finding her magical bottle on a deserted island. Although Nelson sets Jeannie free, she immediately falls in love with him and chooses to stay with her new “master.” It was one of the most viewed series of its time and was also nominated for an Emmy. And even today ‘I dream of Jeannie’ attracts many viewers. But sadly, the show was full of stereotypes and showed negative versions of Arabs and Muslims. One survey that was conducted on the show by Katherine bullock shows that Muslims are most often offended by the show whereas the Non-Muslims didn’t notice any negative stereotyping. So what were the stereotypes in “I dream of Jeannie”? Scholars have stated that early Hollywood ...
Read more